Analysis of Cost Price and Net Profit of Paraclinic Services in Private and Public Sectors: A Case Study of Kerman City 2014

Document Type : Articles

Authors

Abstract

Introduction: Cost is becoming a growing concern for the managers of health and treatment institutes both in private and public sectors. Based on the opinions of pathology and radiology specialists and experts, one private and one public center for radiology and laboratory were selected to study in Kerman City.Method: This is a cross-sectional and applied study. The two centers were similar in frequency of their services, different tests they were conducting, and their number of personnel. Afterwards, the costs of services in both fields were determined using the activity-based costing method. This study was carried out from March 21 to September 22, 2014. The costs of services in both private and public sectors were compared to the tariffs of the Ministry of Health in 2014.Results: Laboratory results indicated that the costs in all the selected tests were higher than the tariffs and the largest difference (app. 84,930 Rls) was observed in the TSH test while the smallest difference was observed in the ferritin test (11,940 Rls). However in the private sector, vitamin D and FBS tests were not profitable with differences of about 5500 and 6500 Rls, respectively. In other tests, the costs in the private sector were lower than the tariffs for the private sector. In the private sector radiology center, only the MRI services were not profitable but the other services were. The cost of MRI services in the private sector studied in this research was 190,000 Rls higher than the private sector tariffs.Conclusion: In this study, the results showed that CT scan services were the most profitable services and the price difference was about 203,000 Rls per service. However, all of the radiology services were unprofitable in the public sector and the largest price difference was seen in MRI services which was about 590,000 Rls per service.Keywords: Radiology, Laboratory, Cost price, Activity-based costing, Private and public tariffs

  1. Safdari R. [The extent and causes of deductions from financial statements of hospitals affiliated with Tehran University of Medical Sciences]. Journal of the Paramedical School of Tehran University of Medical Sciences (Payavard-e Salamt). 2011;5(2).
  2. Yusefzadeh H, Ghaderi H, *, Bagherzade R , Barouni M, The Efficiency and Budgeting of Public Hospitals: Case Study of Iran. Iranian Red Crescent Medical Journal,2013; 15(5).
  3. Hadian M. [Analysis and estimation of costs of services using the step-down cost accounting method]. Modiriat-e Salamat Journal. 2009;37(12).
  4. Zavvareh SH. Establishment of activity based costing. Quarterly of Educational Innovations. 2010;36.
  5. Hozouri MJ, Moqarab SM, Janati A. [Identifying the requirements for operational budgeting in medical universities of Iran]. The Second International Conference of Iranian Medical Sciences Universities2009.
  6. Hundal M. Product costing: a comparison of conventional and activity-based costing methods. Journal of Engeering Design. 1997;8(1):91-103.7.
  7. Nasiripour. [Calculating the cost price of clinical laboratory services in ValiAsr Hospital of Tehran in 2008 using the activity based costing method]. Bimarestan Quarterly. 2009;3, 4.
  8. Goeree MR, Gafni A, Hannah M, Myhr T, Blackhouse G. Hospital Selection for unit cost estimates in multicentre economic evaluations. Pharmacoeconomics. 1999;15(6):561-72.
  9. Mousavi. [Analysis of the average cost price of treatment services in the inpatient and imaging units of the Al-Zahra Training and Treatment Center of Isfahan and a comparison between this cost price and average services tariff]. Modiriat-e Etelaat-e Salamat Journal.7(2 (consecutive no 14)).
  10. SABER MA, BAROUNI M, BAHRAMI MA, GOODARZI G, SHEIKHGHOLAMI S, EBRAHIMIPOUR Z, et al. COST PRICE ESTIMATION OF RADIOLOGY SERVICES IN SHAFA HOSPITAL, KERMAN, 2010. 2011.
  11. Ghiasvand H. [Calculating the cost price of radiology services using the activity based costing method]. Payesh Journal. 2013;6.
  12. Torabi A. [Calculation of the cost price of radiology services in 2009 in Golestan Teaching Hospital of Ahwaz]. Payesh Journal. 2011;2.
  13. J